NYC Cooperative Board of Managers Legal Guide

BY JOHN KIRITSIS, ESQ., CPA, MBA, MS, JD, LL.M

The Board of Managers of a cooperative (co-op) in New York City (NYC) plays a crucial role in managing the operations, finances, and governance of the co-op. This legal guide provides an overview of the responsibilities, powers, and legal considerations that pertain to NYC co-op Boards of Managers:

**1. Responsibilities and Powers:

Fiduciary Duty: Board members have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the co-op and its shareholders.

Decision-Making: The Board is responsible for making decisions that affect the co-op, such as budgeting, maintenance, repairs, and rule enforcement.

Rule-Making: The Board has the authority to establish and enforce rules and policies for the co-op community.

Financial Management: The Board oversees financial matters, including creating budgets, setting maintenance fees, and managing reserves.

Contract Negotiations: The Board negotiates and approves contracts with vendors, contractors, and service providers.

Maintenance and Repairs: The Board ensures that the co-op property is well-maintained and repairs are conducted when necessary.

Governance and Decision-Making:

Meetings: The Board should hold regular meetings to discuss and make decisions on important matters.

Minutes: Accurate minutes should be kept for all Board meetings to document decisions, discussions, and actions taken.

Voting: Decisions are typically made through voting. Major decisions may require a supermajority vote as outlined in the bylaws.

Legal and Regulatory Compliance:

Bylaws and Proprietary Lease: The co-op’s governing documents (bylaws and proprietary lease) define the powers and responsibilities of the Board.

Local Laws: The Board must comply with NYC laws and regulations related to housing, zoning, safety, and more.

Fair Housing Laws: The Board must adhere to fair housing laws and cannot discriminate in the application and approval process.

Shareholder Meetings: The Board is responsible for organizing annual shareholder meetings to provide updates and address concerns.

Transparency and Communication:

Shareholder Communication: The Board should maintain open communication with shareholders through regular updates and announcements.

Transparency: Decisions and actions of the Board should be communicated transparently to shareholders.

Legal Considerations:

Liability Protection: Board members have limited liability protection under the Business Judgment Rule, provided decisions are made in good faith.

Insurance: The co-op should have appropriate insurance coverage to protect the Board and shareholders from potential liabilities.

Conflicts of Interest: Board members should avoid conflicts of interest and disclose any potential conflicts that arise.

Professional Guidance:

Legal Counsel: The Board should consult with legal professionals who specialize in NYC co-op law for guidance on legal matters and compliance.

Financial Experts: Engage financial experts to ensure proper financial management and reporting.

Remember that co-op governance is complex, and specific situations may vary. This guide provides a general overview, but legal advice tailored to your co-op’s unique circumstances is essential. Consult legal professionals and experts who specialize in NYC co-op law for accurate and up-to-date guidance.

Citations, References and Potentially Useful Resources for Further Information:

U.S. Constitution

New York State Constitution

Federal Securities Regulation

New York State Martin Act

New York Condominium Act

New York State Security Regulations

New York Business Corporation Law

New York Limited Liability Company Law

New York Uniform Partnership Act

Federal Internal Revenue Code

New York State Tax Laws, Rules & Regulations

New York City Tax Laws, Rules & Regulations

Winston Churchill Owners, Inc. v. Regents Real Estate Associates

Board of Managers of the Park Regis Condominium v. Park Regis Owners Corp.

Park Sutton Condominium v. 447 E. 57th St. LLC

28 E. 10th Street Corp. v. Veras

Riverside Syndicate, Inc. v. Munroe

Essex House Condominium v. Marks

The Parc Vendome Condominium v. Atkinson

54-56 Meserole Street Owners Corp. v. Rossi

The Beekman Regent Condominium v. Bottiglieri

Chelsea 19th LLC v. West 19th Street Realty LLC

ACRIS

New York Department of Finance

New York City Department of Buildings

New York City Bar Association

New York State Bar Association

Call 212 922 0005. Kiritsis Law Group.

Manhattan Office: 633 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017. Phone# 212 922 0005.

New Jersey Office: 7309 Ventnor Avenue, Ventnor, NJ 08406. Phone# 212 922 0005.

Brooklyn Office: 6902 11th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11228. Phone# 212 922 0005.

Feel free to call us at 212-922-0005 for a free, brief and confidential consultation.

Whether buying real estate, having years of un-filed tax returns, have an immigration question, considering to start a business, faced with a commercial/business dispute or thinking about getting a prenuptial agreement — Our law firm is willing, able and ready to assist you. Call us at 212 922 0005.

We represent businesses and individuals throughout the 5 boroughs of New York City and most of New Jersey.

For a free, brief initial phone consultation with an attorney, call us today at 212 922 0005.

Our law firm provides a full range of legal services, within the following practice areas:

Real Estate

Business Law

Tax & Accounting Services

Immigration Law

Asset Protection

Business/Commercial Litigation & Disputes

The materials available through this website and any other websites owned by John Kiritsis (individually and collectively, the “Website”) are the property of John Kiritsis and his entities, and are protected by copyright, trademark, and other intellectual property laws. You may not use, reproduce, download, store, post, broadcast, transmit, modify, sell, or make available to the public content from the Website without the prior written approval of John Kiritsis. Beware that any unauthorized use of John Kiritsis’ trademarks and copyrighted content for commercial purposes in violation of John Kiritsis’s intellectual property rights, will be vigorously enforced. All other trademarks, service marks and trade names referenced in this site are the property of John Kiritsis.

ANY AND ALL INFORMATION POSTED IN THIS WEBSITE SHALL NOT BE A SUBSTITUTE FOR LEGAL ADVISE BY PROPERLY LICENSED COMPETENT ATTORNEYS. FOR INFORMATIONAL ENTERTAINMENT PURPOSES ONLY. NOT SUBJECTED TO FINALIZED LEGAL EDIT WITH REGARDS TO CONTENT. SITE PRONE TO CONTAINING ERRORS OF STATEMENT OF LAWS, RULES AND/OR REGULATIONS WHERE APPLICABLE.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE A SIMILAR OUTCOME.

The views expressed by this author are not legally binding or reflective of the author, the author’s firm, the author’s employers, the author’s employees, or any individual and/or organization.

ARTICLE#73

NYC Condo Board Liability Exposure

BY JOHN KIRITSIS, ESQ., CPA, MBA, MS, JD, LL.M

Condominium board members in New York City (NYC) have various responsibilities and duties, and with those responsibilities come potential liability exposures. It’s important for condo board members to understand these exposures and take measures to minimize them. Here are some key areas of liability exposure for NYC condo board members:

Fiduciary Duty:

Condo board members have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the condominium association and its unit owners. Breach of this duty, such as mismanagement of funds or self-dealing, can result in legal claims against board members.

Financial Mismanagement:

Board members are responsible for managing the association’s finances, including budgeting, collecting assessments, and allocating funds. Mismanagement of funds or failure to properly oversee financial matters can lead to lawsuits by unit owners.

Contractual Obligations:

Condo boards enter into contracts with vendors, contractors, and service providers for various purposes. If the board fails to fulfill its contractual obligations or engages in negligent selection of vendors, it can lead to disputes and legal claims.

Rule Enforcement and Discrimination:

If the condo board enforces rules inconsistently or discriminates against certain unit owners, it can result in claims of discrimination, harassment, or violations of fair housing laws.

Maintenance and Safety Issues:

Failure to properly maintain common areas and address safety concerns can result in accidents, injuries, and subsequent lawsuits from injured parties.

Privacy Violations:

Improper handling of personal information or violations of privacy rights can lead to legal claims.

Construction Defects:

If the condo board is involved in overseeing new construction or renovation projects and defects arise, board members could face legal action from unit owners or contractors.

Environmental and Health Hazards:

Failure to address environmental hazards or health concerns, such as mold, lead, or asbestos, can result in health-related claims.

Shareholder Disputes:

Conflicts with unit owners over issues like assessments, maintenance, or use of common areas can escalate into legal disputes.

Failure to Disclose:

Failure to provide accurate and complete information to potential buyers about the condo’s financial health, rules, or other matters can lead to claims of misrepresentation.

To minimize liability exposure, NYC condo board members should:

Act in good faith and in the best interests of the association.

Be well-informed about the condo’s governing documents, bylaws, and applicable laws.

Maintain accurate records of meetings, decisions, and actions taken.

Obtain professional advice when needed, including legal counsel and financial experts.

Communicate openly and transparently with unit owners.

Follow proper procedures for decision-making, rule enforcement, and financial management.

It’s advisable for condo boards to carry directors and officers (D&O) liability insurance to help protect board members from certain legal claims. Consulting with legal professionals who specialize in NYC condominium law is essential to understanding and addressing specific liability risks.